CTM Hybrid Meeting – Monday, Sept 9, 2024

The public is welcome to attend. Public input on CTM agenda items will be heard after Trustee discussion is complete.  Community members wishing to address the Board on an agenda item should sign up to speak at least 24 hours before start of the meeting by completing this Google form or with an email request directed to the president at contactctm@cliftoncommunity.org. Individual input on agenda items will last no more than two minutes.

Community members may speak on non-agenda issues during the public questions and concerns period at the end of the meeting. Individuals with statements are asked to sign in before the start of the meeting. Such statements should last not more than two minutes and are invited during the public questions and concerns period. Email your request to speak (specify the topic), or to request an agenda item at the next meeting to contactctm@cliftoncommunity.org.

Agenda

Join in-person: Clifton Recreation Center, 320 McAlpin Avenue  
Join Remotely: https://meet.google.com/qym-wjou-ncx

StartTopicTopic Lead
7:00PMWelcomePresident Steve Goodin
7:01Roll Call/ Approve prior month’s minutesSecretary Barry Gee
7:03Treasurer’s ReportTreasurer Gerald Checco
7:06Fire Report 
7:09Police ReportOfficer Dent (Neighborhood Officer)
7:14Public Safety Committee UpdateUCPD Patrolling UC Adjacent NeighborhoodsBurnet Woods UpdateSafety on LudlowTim Noonan
7:27Presentation Deaconess WoodsScott Allgyer, Patrick Donnelly and Eric Russo
7:42Clifton Golf Outing ReportJohn Whedon
7:45Bus Rapid Transit (BRT)  UpdateGerald Checco and Justin Ogilby
7:48Transportation Committee UpdateCommunity Budget Request (CBR) Update – Business District Crosswalk Improvements (Motion 1)Clifton Avenue Redesign Update – Project Background and Status UpdateJustin Ogilby
8:08Communication Committee Chair UpdateSteve Goodin
8:10 Communication Committee MailChimp Update (Motion 2)Ben Pantoja
8:15Governance Committee ReportBen Pantoja
8:18Diggs Plaza ReportGerald Checco
8:21Clifton Plan UpdateRachel Wells, Nestor Melnyk and Gerald Checco
8:24Welcome & Connect Committee – Welcome & Connect Fest ReportMindi Rich and Gerald Checco
8:27Connected Communities UpgradeSteve Goodin
8:32CTM TTEE’s/ElectionTim Noonan
8:35Clifton Community Fund (CCF) UpdateGerald Checco
8:38CliftonFest Revival Meeting OverviewJan Brown Checco
8:43Committees Roll CallSteve Goodin
8:46Community Questions/ConcernsSteve Goodin
8:51Adjournment – Next meeting October 7, 2024Steve Goodin

MOTIONS

MotionSponsorDescription
1Transportation CommitteeTo request DOTE to:Retime pedestrian crossing signals at Telford, Middleton, and Whitfield to reduce pedestrian wait times. Install centerline hardening at Ludlow/Middleton, Ludlow/Whitfield, Ludlow/Ormond. Remove left-turn prohibition from Ludlow onto Middleton, Ormond
2Communications CommitteeMailChimp Upgrade

 

Ludlow Avenue Safety Improvement

CTM’s Transportation and Public Safety Committee has been working to make Ludlow Avenue safer for all users of this road (vehicle drivers, bicyclists, pedestrians). This website post provides all the details of what has been happening as well as including a Call for Feedback opportunity for everyone in Clifton to act upon. We urge you to review everything below, and the Call for Feedback is near the end.

Timeline

  1. July 2018 – City of Cincinnati Department of Transportation and Engineering (DOTE) requests CTM to submit priority locations for pedestrian safety improvements.
  2. Sep 2018 – CTM submits three locations to City of Cincinnati in response to the July 2018 request: Ludlow Avenue at Morrison Avenue/Place, Ludlow Avenue at Clifton Hills Avenue, and Ludlow Avenue at Ormond Avenue.  Location selection was based on the results of a City of Cincinnati Pedestrian Safety Survey, persistent problem areas received by CTM, and areas without recent improvement activity by the city.
  3. May 2019 – City of Cincinnati releases list of 2019 Pedestrian Safety Program Projects. The Ludlow at Clifton Hills is the only location selected for project funding. A radar sign is selected as the solution.
  4. June 2019 – DOTE Pedestrian Safety Manager (M. McVay) informs CTM that the Clifton Hills location scored above the “finding line” and the request for the Morrison location scored just below. However, the City’s Pedestrian Safety team had significant concerns about striping crosswalks at those two locations, given the volume and speed of traffic and the considerable distance a pedestrian would cross (i.e. four lanes of traffic with no refuge island). The Pedestrian Safety team proposes a safety study (conducted and funded by the Ohio Department of Transportation – ODOT) to identify changes to Ludlow Avenue that would have a positive impact on speeding and pedestrian safety.
  5. July 2019 – CTM Board votes to request safety study of Ludlow Avenue
  6. Oct 2019 – City DOTE advises CTM that ODOT has approved and agreed to do a Safety Study of Ludlow Ave.
  7. April 2020 – Announcement at April CTM monthly meeting that a Ludlow Ave safety study is underway by ODOT from Central Parkway to Whitfield Ave.  
  8. June 2020 – Announcement at June CTM monthly meeting that the report from ODOT is forthcoming.
  9. July 2020 – CTM Board reviews the ODOT report at July CTM monthly meeting and agrees to the objectives of the project. Click here to see the entire ODOT report. The ODOT report includes a separate appendix file which you read by clicking here.
  10. Oct 2020 – City DOTE presents six high-level design options, as well as their various preferred and rejected options for Ludlow Ave at the October CTM monthly meeting and next steps are outlined.  Three designs that met community goals were selected for development of detailed plans and community feedback.

October Initial Presentation by City DOTE

Below is the presentation that City DOTE presented at the October 5, 2020 CTM meeting showing preferred and rejection options. Please note that these options are high level conceptual and not detailed designs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the goals of this effort?

The goals were reviewed and approved by the CTM Board in July 2020. They are as follows:

  1. Make Ludlow Avenue safer and more convenient for pedestrians to cross, with priority locations at:
    • Ludlow at Morrison Avenue/Morrison Place
    • Ludlow at Clifton Hills Ave
  2. Calm vehicular traffic on Ludlow Ave to support Goal #1, and to
    • Calm traffic entering the business district
      • Slow vehicles to 25 MPH
      • Incorporate street features to prepare and welcome approaching traffic
    • Address crashes in area of Ludlow Avenue and Whitfield Avenue
    • Facilitate left turns from Ludlow Avenue to streets and driveways
    • Reduce lane changing, weaving, and passing of vehicles
  3. Extend bike lanes on Ludlow Avenue to connect neighborhood, business district, and Burnet Woods to
    • Central Parkway bike lanes
    • Mill Creek Greenway Trail
    • CROWN and Wasson Way
  4. Maintain safe and efficient access to and movement of busses and public transportation
    • METRO buses
    • School buses
    • Private shuttles (i.e., UC, CCHMC)
  5. Maintain adequate on-street parking for residents and visitors

Why is this project happening?

To make Ludlow Avenue safer by easing traffic flow and making it more convenient and safer to cross Ludlow Avenue.  The background is this: In 2018, the Clifton community through Clifton Town Meeting (CTM) had requested crosswalks be put in at Morrison Avenue and Clifton Hills Avenue at Ludlow.  The City’s Department of Engineering & Transportation (DOTE) indicated that the traffic flow was such that there needed to be a study.  The Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) fielded a traffic study from the Viaduct to Whitfield Avenue and determined that a “road diet” and several safety improvements with crosswalks would reduce accidents by 38%.  

What will change with parking?  

There is no option under consideration where parking is eliminated completely on both sides of the street.  Having “adequate parking” was a criterion of determining which option on which to move forward.  However, the options laid out by DOTE have different implications for parking – some keep parking on both sides and some have it only on one side of the street.  If an option with parking on one side of the street is a preferred option, then DOTE – with heavy engagement by CTM – will conduct a study of parking to determine where parking is being utilized to determine the best configuration. 

Will my driveway be blocked with a median? 

No, at this time there are no plans to block access to any driveway with a median. The ODOT report recommended a center turn lane and DOTE in their options has laid out that there could be a raised median at different parts of the road.  The options under consideration do NOT include any approval or disapproval of a median.  Instead, a decision on the length of a median, its placement, etc would be made at a future date with considerable input from residents along Ludlow Avenue. 

How is the project funded? If I live on Ludlow Avenue will I have to pay for this?

This project will be submitted for funding to the Ohio Department of Transportation in April 2021.  Residents of Clifton (or on Ludlow Avenue) will NOT have to directly pay for it. 

When would construction begin?

Construction would be expected to begin during the Summer of 2022 and finish the same year.

How will the bike lanes be configured?

The different options also include different configurations of bike lanes ranging from a bike lane by the curb with a buffer of parked cars to a bike lane next to traffic and parked cars to a two-way fully protected bike lane on one side of the street.  Depending on which option is chosen, DOTE will then do more detailed by-block drawings.  They have been clear that none of the options would block driveways or bus stops.  

What new crosswalks will be added on this project?  

Pedestrian crosswalk locations are being proposed at the intersections of Ludlow at Clifton Hills Ave. and Ludlow at Morrison Ave./Morrison Place with Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons (RRFBs).

What is a rectangular rapid flashing beacon? 

Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons (RRFBs) are used to supplement warning signs at uncontrolled intersections or mid-block crosswalks. They feature flashing, high-intensity LEDs that alert motorists that pedestrians are using the crosswalk. Studies have shown that RRFBs significantly increase driver yielding behavior.  RRFBs are placed on both sides of a crosswalk below a pedestrian crossing sign and above an arrow sign that points at the crossing. Pedestrians manually activate RRFBs with a push-button. An example of this can be found at the intersection of Central Parkway at Clifton Hills Avenue.

Call for Feedback

City DOTE has agreed to collect all the feedback on this project. They have created a website link for our neighborhood to use. Please click here to give your feedback.

Next Steps

  • Provide feedback now through December 3.
  • CTM Transportation Committee presents recommendation on a path forward on the options to the CTM Board of Trustees. Trustees will endeavor to decide on proceeding with the Ludlow Road Diet and also direction on which option to proceed with in order to enable DOTE to move forward. You can attend this virtual meeting. Watch for the announcement via email to subscribers with the details on how to join online. It will also be posted on Facebook, NextDoor, and on this website as a separate posting.
  • During the winter, City DOTE will prepare a project for submission to ODOT in April 2021 to gain approved funding through ODOT’s Safety Improvement program. CTM Transportation Committee will engage with DOTE on issues around details of design drawings, studies on parking implications, medians, etc. and will engage with the community as they become available.
  • Assuming approval for funding is achieved, construction and installation would start during the Summer of 2022.

Ludlow Business District Parking Restrictions Removal

CTM is pleased to announce that the City of Cincinnati’s Department of Traffic and Engineering (DOTE) has made rush hour parking permanent along the business district on Ludlow Avenue.  This announcement was the result of a three-month pilot requested by CTM.  That pilot demonstrated a 25% reduction in traffic accidents and a 3x decrease in serious injuries.  During the pandemic, it has also enabled parking to be used by patrons of businesses.  Thanks to the CTM Transportation & Public Safety Committee and DOTE for working this issue.

Click here to read about the launching of the trial.

Click here to read about when CTM asked for feedback about the trial.

CTM Moves to Explore Rush Hour Parking Trial

During the June 2019 CTM meeting, Trustees voted to ask the City to implement a trial to remove the rush hour parking restrictions on Ludlow Avenue. The full details of the motion are below. The focus of this effort is to improve pedestrian safety. The Northside neighborhood successfully completed a similar trial in their neighborhood recently. While we don’t know the outcome of this trial, we are hopeful it will illuminate ways to improve pedestrian safety.

Trustees agreed to hold public engagement sessions as part of this trial to ensure plenty of input is obtained. Please watch for emailed announcements of these engagements. If you are not a subscriber, please click here to do so.

WCPO published an article recently regarding this effort. Click here to read it.

In a related matter, CTM also voted to explore a trial of bump outs on Ludlow Avenue through the CTM Business Committee. These also have the potential to improve pedestrian safety.

Motion for Rush Hour Parking

Clifton Town Meeting respectfully requests that the City plan and implement a trial for a period lasting not less than 3 months, but not greater than 6 months, with the exact dates to be determined in coordination with the City Department of Transportation and Engineering (DOTE) with the following parameters:

  1. Remove all (AM & PM) rush-hour parking restrictions on Ludlow Av between Cornell Pl and Brookline Av
  2. Prior to implementation of the trial, CTM requests DOTE either confirm the existence of or DOTE gather the appropriate data to ensure a “before change” data set exists.
  3. DOTE assist in evaluating the impact of the trial on safety, traffic, and business; and in determining the advisability of making permanent changes and/or conducting further trials.
  4. The CTM Transportation & Public Safety Committee will be the lead group of CTM on this effort and will make monthly progress reports to the CTM Board along with updates as needed between monthly reports. The Committee will advise the Board of all meetings in advance in case other Trustees want to attend to learn more details of what is happening.
  5. The noted CTM Committee will hold public engagement sessions in a variety of methods before, during, and after the trial. Methods shall include but are not limited to, single topic public in-person meetings & online surveys. The Committee will work closely with DOTE on these engagement methods to ensure appropriate information/data is gathered. The Committee will work with a professional to ensure any survey is unbiased and fit for purpose. Engagement will not delay the implementation of the trial.
  6. No monies will be spent by CTM on this matter without a future vote of the Board of Trustees.
  7. A letter summarizing the trial request will be sent to DOTE on or before June 15 by the CTM President or his designee.